Pipe Dreams

“The USMNT will be good enough to compete in the World Cup.”

“Soccer will finally take off and become popular in the United States.”

“The Maine Democratic Party won’t shoot itself in the foot this election cycle.”

“Large-scale test results can be used to inform instruction.”

All of the above fit the classic definition of a pipe dream; that is, “an idea plan, or hope that is unrealistic, impractical, or nearly impossible to achieve.” The other critical component of each of those pipe dreams is that we are able to convince ourselves that it is achievable, repeatedly and often in the face of daunting evidence. Education policy, specifically policy related to assessment is rife with such pipe dreams. The questions I ponder this week, as we look to the future of assessment, is the extent to which pipe dreams are a necessary evil and when is it time to let go of them.

America 250 – Coloring Within The Lines

It’s America’s 250th birthday. That anniversary has me thinking about US History and the Wizard’s quote from the musical Wicked, “where I’m from, we believe all sorts of things that aren’t true… we call it history.”  One of the few things that’s clear to me about history is that the past is constantly changing. With that in mind, in today’s post, I take a look back at one view of US history from the Bicentennial in 1976.  And I pose this question to you, if asked to design a 32-item test or 32-week course on US History from 1776-1976, how would your view differ from the one presented in the post? What events and people would you include? 

Showing Some Love for the OG NAEP

It’s common knowledge that for technical and practical reasons I’m not a big fan of preserving NAEP trends. I’m a little suspect of trying to stretch test scales across decades back to the 1990s, let alone back to the 1970s. That being said, I’m also one who respects history and lineage. And as we emerge from Father’s Day weekend, it’s appropriate to take a little time to pay homage to the “father” of the current NAEP assessment and those who championed its cause. I think that it’s safe to say that without the solid foundation laid by the NAEP Long Term Trend assessment, the Main NAEP with its state-level results wouldn’t have gotten off the ground in the 1990s. 

Ten Numbers That Shook My World

We all have them. The images that we can never unsee. The quote, song lyric, or perhaps poem that we never forget. That friend, colleague, or chance interaction that had a profound impact on us. Having spent my life immersed in data, I guess that it makes sense that I also have a list of ten numbers or statistics that shook my professional world. I discuss those numbers in today’s “very special” blog post. That is, it’s way too long, but like Netflix, I give you the option to binge this as a naughty summer reading treat or to break up the 10 self-contained “episodes” on your own.

American Education: A Tangled Can of Monkeys

Try as I might, my mind just won’t let go of the story about the school year for Pawtucket, Rhode Island elementary school students being extended because it was discovered that the school day has been 5 minutes too short. From beginning to end, from regulation to problem to solution to acceptance, the issue in Pawtucket, is a microcosm of the complexities that are going to make it so difficult to reform public education in the United States. 

Culture > Curriculum > Courses

As I leaf through excited posts and articles about how AI is going to help assess durable skills and bring to life the freshly painted portraits of high school graduates, I start to get an uneasy feeling in the pit of my stomach and a tightness in my chest. My fear is that once again we’re going to do this backwards, that is by beginning with assessment. It’s critical, particularly with these the types of skills that are being discussed today that we remember to consider curriculum before assessment and more importantly, culture before curriculum. 

Assessment ________ Learning

The relationship between assessment and learning is one that we’ve been struggling to understand for as long as I can remember. Before we jump headlong into reimagining assessment, it will be beneficial to clarify what we mean by both terms as well as the relationship(s) between them. 

Let’s begin with a simple filling in the blank item:  Assessment ______ Learning.

The Tale Of The Tape

All signs suggest that we might finally be emerging from our decade-long period of malaise regarding large-scale testing. Advances in AI, flexibility from the feds, and new buckets of money are making people giddy. Happy Days Are Here Again! In such heady times, however, it’s critical that we step back and take a sober look at our place in the education world.

The Real World of Educational Measurement

Educational measurement begins in the real world. On that point there seems to be universal agreement. Where, however, does it end? Consensus on that question is not quite as strong. For a while now, I’ve had a nagging feeling that something was missing from our definition of educational measurement. Educational measurement has to end where it began; that is, in the real world.